Inspiration for my columns comes from a variety of sources. This one is dedicated to my smart, but headstrong, teenage niece.
UV LEDs are teenagers. Commercially available UV LEDs – that by today’s standards were relatively low power – first appeared somewhere around 2003. By 2008, power levels had increased and unit costs had dropped, making UV LEDs a viable alternative for some types of curing applications. As UV LEDs enter their teenage years, their increased power and bandwidths have made them a viable alternative for new uses and applications.
Based on my early career experience teaching middle and high school science and coaching teenagers, I can unequivocally state that the Russian proverb popularized by President Reagan – “Doveryai, no Proveryai” (“Trust but Verify”) – applies to both teenagers and UV LEDs. Full Disclosure: I consider myself lucky that cell phones and social media were not around to document my teenage misadventures.
This issue’s column starts with a look at UV LED technologies and finishes with an interview with GEW (EC) Limited’s Robert Rae, managing director – sales, and Jennifer Heathcote, business development manager.
Part One: What Needs to be Verified?
Power: With great power comes great…?
Teenagers: Listen to teen athletes trash talk in the gym and you will hear: “How much can you bench press? Dude, I just did 240 pounds.” The talk most often refers to the maximum weight for a one-time bench press. What if the best performance is achieved by finding the weight amount the teens could bench press 10 times? Or 20 times? Are there parallels with how formulations perform? Do some formulations react better to single high-intensity exposure and others react better to a longer exposure of lower intensity?
LEDs: Source suppliers were at one time engaged in their own trash talk with claims of how much power their latest LED delivered: “Dude, I have 24 Watts/cm2 at 395 nm! The early thinking was that the higher the irradiance, the better the LED. Where was the value measured? What happens to the life of the LED if it is run continuously at that output level? Today’s LEDs, in most cases, deliver plenty of power and you should (hopefully) hear discussion of both irradiance (W/cm2) and energy density (J/cm2) values. Most importantly, what does your formulation and process need?
Advice: Where did you get that advice?
Teenagers: Adults – as well as teenagers – can be led astray with information gathered from “friends” or the internet. We work to educate our teenagers about being careful but sometimes forget it ourselves. Abraham Lincoln first pointed this out in 1862 when he stated: “The trouble with information on the internet is that you never know if it is genuine.”
LEDs: When it comes to UV and UV LEDs, the spectrum of knowledge runs from excellent to poor. Qualify the source of the advice and question if it makes sense. When measuring LEDs, using instruments with responses optimized for broadband sources or without the correct dynamic range can be extremely misleading.
Truth: Can you tell me the ‘whole’ truth and not a partial story with ‘holes’ in it?
Teenagers: Do your teenagers get frustrated with your probing questions? Does getting the whole story feel like an interrogation? Sometimes, technology can be a good thing for a parent. Online grade reporting makes it harder to change a “D” into a “B” and cell phones can be used to corroborate information.
LEDs: Customers get frustrated when I ask multiple questions to fully understand their situation. Verify the information below to get the whole truth about your source, formulation and measurement of an LED process.
Center Wavelength (CWL): LEDS are specified with an expected range of their most intense output. Most LEDs use a +/- 5 nanometer (nm) tolerance, which means the peak output for 395 nm should fall between 390 nm and 400 nm. Verify this, especially if you are testing multiple sources or have multiple wavelength LEDs available.
Optics: Does your LED utilize secondary optics to redirect the energy coming from the diodes? If comparing two different sources, this could impact the UV being delivered.
Maintenance: Follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for maintaining your LED. Check and keep the quartz window clean.
Power Rating/Setting: Verify the power class of your LED and the selected setting (percentage) on your power supply. The power delivered to and measured at the substrate level normally is less than the rated LED power value. Verify that your LED can deliver the appropriate number of both Watts and Joules.
Heat: LEDs are cooler than broadband sources but not completely heat free. Understand how this impacts
Process Window: Do you have a process window set up with the CWL spectral output of the LED specified along with target Watt and Joule targets?
Surface Cure: Does the LED provide adequate surface cure, or do you need a “boost” from a shortwave rich UV source, PI package or special inerting?
Other: Are there any other variables that you need
Instrument Response: Verify that the instrument responsivity is optimized for your LED.
Dynamic Range: Verify that the instrument dynamic range is optimized for your LED.
Instrument Sample Rate: The footprint of many LEDs is smaller than that of mercury-based sources, which means the time under the UV source will be much shorter. Verify that the sample rate of your radiometer will support the speed at which you plan to collect data.
Data: Organize your data and record all information (W/cm2, J/cm2) that is available from the instrument. If your instrument supports transfer of additional data, like the irradiance profile, also save that information. Attach notes if possible.
Stability: We ask customers to take three sets of data with a single instrument under the same exact process conditions to understand the stability of their system and data collection process. After we understand a system, we then will investigate readings between multiple instruments and/or multiple sources.
Closeups: LEDs have thousands of individual point sources. Positioning the instrument optics at different positions under the LED quartz window can lead to slight differences in the readings, especially if you are extremely close to the quartz window of the LED.
Instrument Care: Follow the guidelines from the manufacturer on how to use, care for and clean your instrument. Do not forget that your instruments need periodic calibration and service.
Parting Thought: “I thought raising teenagers would be like those goofy old Brady Bunch episodes about curfews, acne and dating. It is not. It is more like Survivor meets Dateline: Hang in there and do not murder anyone.”
Quote from www.raisingteenstoday.com
Part Two: Interview on LED Technology with Robert Rae and Jennifer Heathcote
of GEW (EC) Limited
As UV LEDs enter their teenage years, how have they changed, and what can you share about dealing with them?
Jennifer: In 2007, when I began working with UV LEDs, there were few practical applications. Early LED systems mainly were used in formulation labs, with R&D efforts focused on spot cure (adhesive structural bonding) and printing (digital inkjet pinning and eventually full-cure) applications. There were many in the industry who doubted whether UV LED technology could be a viable replacement for mercury lamps and believed the technology was limited to a few markets.
LEDs improved over the next five years. Irradiance (W/cm2) levels increased tremendously but often were still on the edge of what was needed for surface chemistry crosslinking. Energy density (J/cm2) levels also limited line speeds and part cycle times. This was compounded by the high cost, short lifetimes and cooling demands of UV diodes that made higher power lamp heads and longer length arrays economically difficult to justify.
Teenaged UV LEDs of 2021 are far superior and emit more than enough irradiance for UV curing applications when compared to their younger versions. A renewed focus on the role of energy density combined with proper integration and optimized formulations are enabling converting line speeds of 1000 to 1500 fpm and greater. Like a teenager, today’s LED lamp heads have grown and are being manufactured in single, continuous lamp head lengths up to 67 inches (1.7 meters).
Rob: We feel that LED curing is the present and future of UV curing. If you have a new UV project and have not considered LED, you are making a mistake. There are relatively few applications remaining where LED is not viable at least from a process standpoint. In terms of reliability, cooling is critical and a big performance differentiator among commercially available UV LED systems. The individual diodes are sensitive electronics that must maintain a factory-specified operating temperature and always be kept clean and dry. The LEDs should be sealed from the industrial environment and never exposed outside of a manufacturer’s clean room.
Despite the progress, UV LED technology – like a teenager – is far from mature. Performance and reliability differences exist between manufacturers, and headline-grabbing specifications, such as irradiance and quoted lifetimes, do not give a proper indication of real-world performance or reliability. Investigate the technical details of a system and clarify how the specifications translate to your application. The integration of an LED system into a printing or coating process is just as important as the LED emitter itself. Look beyond the LED head and consider how all systems are seamlessly integrated as a complete solution.
What LED features are considered “need
Rob: LED systems must be designed and matched to the application. Make sure the system selected delivers the needed energy density (J/cm2) and irradiance (W/cm2), as this will impact line speeds and cure performance. For industrial environments, you need sealed windows, sufficient and well-engineered thermal transfer/cooling, and industrial rated connectors. Power supplies, lamp heads and even mounting brackets need to be robust and engineered for the application and machine.
What LED features are nice to have?
Rob: Our customers increasingly appreciate remote system monitoring. IoT technologies are becoming standard issue on industrial equipment and are increasingly specified as a product requirement. Remote monitoring offers many advantages as it allows GEW to commission equipment, update software, monitor system performance data, troubleshoot technical issues and correct processes without having to be physically on site.
When investing in a UV LED system, ask if the equipment is supported by reliable power and control systems. If something happens, how quickly can the supplier diagnose and repair the issue? Remote monitoring is an efficient, timely and cost-effective tool that, while initially is nice to have, quickly becomes something many users are not willing to run without.
What advice do you have for customers looking to adopt a teenager-transition
Rob: If you have the right partners, there is no need to be afraid. LEDs transform the productivity and cost of your printing or coating process and, when done right, offer benefits over traditional broadband UV technology.
Irradiance (W/cm2) is not the most important characteristic of an LED system. Once a system emits above a minimum threshold (e.g., 16 W/cm2 at the emitting window for many web applications), then energy density (mJ/cm2) is the key performance driver. Coordinate with your supplier to match the energy density to the desired line speed. Do not judge an LED system on irradiance alone!
When a UV LED diode is properly cooled and powered, it easily can last 50,000 hours or more. However, there are two things that will kill LEDs in no time.
Poor cooling: This occurs when filters are clogged, water or airflow is interrupted, or the manufacturer has not adequately designed the cooling system for an industrial environment, as well as the system’s running conditions.
Contamination: Individual LEDs and modules should be sealed, remain completely clean and never be exposed outside of the manufacturer’s clean room. Ingress of foreign materials creates hotspots and harms electronics, both of which compromise the integrity of the device.
Integration onto the machine often is as important as the UV emitter itself. Look for a partner with industry experience, strong mechanical capability and application knowledge. Many good LED systems fail because they have been poorly specified for the application and/or hastily or carelessly integrated onto the machine.
Are there common characteristics that make the transition process to LEDs easier?
Jennifer: Formulations also have improved, and there are an increasing number of options. Ensure that the formulations and LED curing system work together for the specified application, material handling and end-use product. A successful change always involves collaboration, getting good advice and after-sale support from team partners.
Rob: Dual-cure ink and varnish sets, which cure when exposed to either a mercury or LED source, are increasingly available. Separate formulation sets were an early barrier to LED adoption. Using a dual-cure formulation eases the transition by eliminating this hurdle and reducing the number of SKUs. This saves time and cost and reduces uncertainty.
What are your thoughts on transitioning with and acquiring individual parts (LED head, power supply, cooling) vs. turning to a supplier that provides an integrated solution?
Rob: When you buy a car, you do not expect to choose a Ford engine, a Chevrolet gearbox and a BMW chassis and put them together yourself. This is because the car manufacturer designs, integrates and tests all components to work together and is the expert at doing so. The same principles apply to curing systems. A UV LED system is about far more than just the lamp head assembly. The long-term reliability and fitness for use is just as much the result of the power supply, the controls, the cooling system and the mechanical integration.
What questions need to be asked
Jennifer: Start discussions with your incumbent suppliers. For existing mercury lines, it is important to determine how many of the formulations currently being used are available in an LED or dual-cure equivalent. Areas that are still in various stages of development include low-migration offerings; functional coatings, such as silicone release, hardcoats, topcoats and surface coats; and formulations designed to adjust coefficient of friction (COF) surface properties. How active and committed is your incumbent supplier to developing LED offerings that are not yet off-the-shelf? End users should clearly communicate specific requirements and anticipated demand early in the conversation. The adage of the squeaky wheel gets the grease holds true even here.
Once you have something, be engaged and test. Test in the lab, test on pilot lines and test on the press. Seeing is believing. Be ready to work and communicate with your supply team. Adjust the formulation, process, equipment and LED power level as needed.
Rob: A conversation around energy density and irradiance is key. Both the formulator and lamp supplier should be able to answer these questions and provide application guidance. If your formulator is using a specific LED configuration in their lab or on a pilot line, it does not mean a different LED specification will not work. For example, if they use 385 nm in the lab, then a 395 nm lamp may work equally well in production. Or if the irradiance of your lab source is particularly high, a lower irradiance lamp often can work just as well if its energy density is significantly higher. The formulator and lamp supplier should be knowledgeable of the interplay between wavelength, irradiance and energy density and how it translates to successful curing in a manufacturing environment.
What role does UV measurement play
in the process?
Rob: Measurement is critical for establishing a baseline operating window on day one. When or if something goes wrong in the future, how will you know what variable changed if you did not measure your process when it was working? It also is important to have regular technical conversations between yourself and your suppliers. Your UV curing process is initiated by UV energy. If you do not have the ability to measure that UV energy, you and your suppliers are shooting in the dark when problem solving. u
For more information, contact Rob Rae (firstname.lastname@example.org) and Jennifer Heathcote (email@example.com).